Meet Christina McGinley

Hi! My name is Christy McGinley. I am an insurance agent with over 25 years of insurance experience. I can help you navigate Medicare and help make sense of all of the options that are available. I represent all of the major carriers, and most of the small ones, and my priority is to find the best plan to fit your individual needs.

Often, Medicare is less expensive and has lower out-of-pocket expenses than group employer coverage and it does not cost you anything to go through me. It is the same price if you enroll online or on the phone with the carrier but when you go through me, I am here for you all year long to help you if any issues arise. I am not a call center and will never solicit you over the phone.

I have a small office in Nashville for appointments however, I primarily work from home and travel all over the beautiful State of Indiana. I offer in-home appointments, am happy to meet you at a coffee shop or restaurant, and also offer phone & virtual appointments.

If you are interested, please feel free to call, email or text me and I would be happy to schedule a time to meet you and thoroughly discuss how I can help find the right plan for you.


McGinley Insurance Agency, Inc.

By Appointment Only
146 E Main St., Suite 5
Nashville, IN 47448


  [email protected]

 Mon - Fri: 9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Sat - Sun: Closed